Journal · · 5 min ← All posts

A document from 1990 cost my title insurance company $185,000. Here's how chain of title works.

By Brent Neely

Every building has a paper trail. It sits at the county recorder’s office and goes back to whoever first owned the dirt.

A few months after I bought an office building in 2022, the City sent me a letter. A 1990 agreement, recorded against my property, said the owner had to build a road. Nobody had told me. It wasn’t on my title policy. The search had missed it.

That road cost $185,000, and my title insurance company paid for it. Here’s how that works.

The chain

When a building sells, the seller signs a deed to the buyer and the deed is recorded at the county. String every sale together, back to the first owner, and you have the chain of title.

Deeds aren’t the only links. Every loan against the property is recorded, and so is every release when a loan gets paid off. So is every easement, every lien, and every agreement someone signed that runs with the land. Some of it is fifty years old and still binding on whoever owns the building today.

Diagram. Each sale and recorded agreement is a link at the county recorder. 1977: a warranty deed reserving a railroad spur easement. 1990: an annexation agreement requiring the owner to build a road. Later deeds, loans and releases. 2022: the deed to me. The 1977 and 1990 items were not listed as exceptions on my 2022 title policy. Every building has a paper trail at the countyThe chain of title on an office building I bought in 2022, simplified1977Warranty deedReserves a railroadspur easement1990Annexation agreementOwner must build aroad for the City1990s to 2010sDeeds, loans,releases2022Deed to meRecorded the daywe closedNot on my 2022 title policy. The search missed both.Every link is recorded at the county. The title company's job is to read all of them before you close.

Where the chain starts

In Idaho, every chain of title starts with the United States government.

On April 19, 1867, a federal surveyor set a single point on a butte south of Boise. Every piece of land in the state is measured from it: so many townships north or south, so many ranges east or west. Before anyone could own a piece of that grid, the government had to deed it to them. That deed is called a land patent, and it’s the first link in every chain. Homesteaders got them, railroads got them, and the federal land records for most of them are still searchable online today.

Five-step timeline. 1867: surveyors establish the Boise Meridian initial point and measure Idaho from it. Then a federal land patent transfers the land from the U.S. government to its first private owner. Later a plat divides it into lots. Every sale, loan and agreement after that is recorded at the county. Today you are the newest link. Every chain starts with the U.S. governmentHow the paper trail on Idaho land begins1867The gridSurveyors set one pointsouth of Boise andmeasure Idaho from it1860s onThe patentThe U.S. governmentdeeds the land to itsfirst private ownerLaterThe platLand gets divided intolots and recordedas a subdivisionEvery saleThe linksDeeds, loans, releases,easements, agreements,all recordedTodayYouThe newest link.Title insurance coversthe ones behind youSources: Bureau of Land Management (Boise Meridian initial point, April 19, 1867; General Land Office patent records).

That’s why the legal description on a deed reads like coordinates instead of an address. Street addresses change. The survey doesn’t.

Diagram. Left: a township, six miles square, numbered into 36 sections; section 7 is highlighted. Right: section 7 enlarged, one square mile or 640 acres, split into four 160-acre quarters; the southwest quarter is highlighted. An example legal description reads part of the southwest quarter of Section 7, Township 3 North, Range 2 East, Boise Meridian. Where your building sits on the gridThe legal description on a deed is an address on the 1867 surveyA township: 6 miles square654321789101112181716151413192021222324302928272625313233343536enlargedSection 7: 1 square mile, 640 acresNW 1/4160 acresNE 1/4160 acresSW 1/4160 acresSE 1/4160 acresYour lot is apiece of oneof theseExample: "Part of the SW 1/4 of Section 7, Township 3 North, Range 2 East, Boise Meridian."Townships are counted north or south and east or west from the 1867 initial point. Illustrative location.

Who does the work

Nobody drives to the courthouse and reads 150 years of books every time a building sells. The county keeps the official record. The title company keeps its own indexed copy, organized by parcel, called a title plant, and does the reading. At closing, escrow pays off the old loans and records your deed. You walk away with an owner’s policy, and your lender gets one of its own.

Four boxes left to right. County recorder keeps every recorded document. The title company searches its indexed copy, a title plant, and issues the commitment and policies. Escrow pays off old loans and records the new deed. The buyer gets an owner's policy and the lender gets a lender's policy. Four parties, one closingWho handles the chain of title when a building sellsCounty recorderKeeps the recordEvery deed, loan, release andagreement, filed by dateTitle companyReads the recordKeeps its own indexed copy (a"title plant") and insures itEscrow at closingMoves money and paperPays off old loans, recordsyour deed the same dayYou and your lenderGet the policiesOwner's policy for you,lender's policy for the bank

What the title company hands you

Before closing, the title company reads that chain and issues a title commitment: a promise to insure the title once certain things happen. It comes in three parts.

Diagram of a title commitment. Schedule A: who owns the property and the legal description. Schedule B Part I: requirements before closing, such as paying off the seller's loan. Schedule B Part II: exceptions the policy will not cover. What the title company hands you before closingA title commitment, in three partsSchedule AWho owns it, and exactly what landOn Aspen: the seller's LLC, and the legal description of the parcel.Schedule B, Part IWhat has to happen before closingOn Aspen: pay off and release the seller's $3.72M loan from 2021.Schedule B, Part IIWhat the policy will not coverEasements, recorded agreements, old reservations. The page to read twice.Aspen figures from the 2026 First American title commitment.

On Aspen, Schedule B Part I is where the seller’s 2021 loan showed up. If that loan isn’t paid off and released at closing, you’ve bought a building with someone else’s lender still attached to it.

Part II is the page that matters most and the one people skip. Anything listed there is something the policy will not cover. Anything the search missed, and that isn’t listed, is something it will.

Two different kinds of insurance

Most people think of insurance as protection against what happens next. Title insurance is the opposite.

Timeline with closing day in the middle. Left: title insurance, one premium paid at closing, covers defects already in the record. Right: property insurance, paid every year, covers fire, storms and accidents after you own it. Title insurance looks backwardProperty insurance covers what happens next. Title insurance covers what already happened.Closing dayTitle insuranceProperty insuranceDefects already in the recordOne premium, paid once at closingFire, storms, accidentsA premium every year

You pay for it once, at closing. It covers you if a problem was already sitting in the record before you bought, and the search should have found it.

How the claim played out

Timeline. October 2022: the City sends a letter citing a 1990 annexation agreement requiring the owner to build a road. December 2022: the title insurer confirms in writing the agreement was missed. 2023: negotiation over cost. 2024: the insurer pays the contractors and the road is built. Claim of about $185,000; the insurer paid the contractors directly. One missed document, $185,000How the claim on my 2022 purchase played outOct 2022City letterA 1990 agreement says theowner builds the roadDec 2022Insurer agreesConfirms in writing thesearch missed it2023NegotiationTheir bid vs. the real costto build it to city spec2024Road builtInsurer pays the pavingand engineering firms$185,000Title insurance claim. The insurer paid the contractors directly.The policy cost one premium, paid once, at closing in 2022.

The 1990 agreement was signed when the land was annexed into the City. It said the developer would build the road once the property next door was developed. Decades later, the property next door got developed, and the City came to the current owner. That was me.

My title company confirmed in writing that its search had missed the agreement. Then came a year of back and forth over what it would actually cost. Their first number covered the pavement. Mine covered the pavement plus the permits, the engineering, the general contractor and the project management a city-spec road actually takes. In 2024 the road got built, and the insurer paid the paving company and the engineers directly.

The policy did exactly what it’s for. It was one premium, paid once, nearly two years before the City’s letter showed up.

It’s also why I read Schedule B line by line on every deal now, instead of trusting that someone else did.

Title is one of the boring things I check on every deal

If you want to see how I put a deal together, start with Aspen, the 45-unit building I bought in Boise this year. Or book 30 minutes, or email me at [email protected].

See the Aspen dealBook a 30-minute call

Thanks,
Brent


This is not legal or investment advice. Neely Property Investments offerings are made under Rule 506(c) to verified accredited investors only.

A short personal note from me most Fridays about what actually happened that week. Subscribe to the Friday letter.

·

Recent posts

How to invest passively in Boise apartments

If you're an accredited investor, the usual way to invest passively in a Boise apartment building is as a limited partner alongside a sponsor who buys it and runs it, typically with a $50,000 minimum. Here's how that works, what the fees usually look like, and why the sponsor's operating record matters more than their deal flow.

Boise apartments are 98.3% full. Four of five deals still didn't sell.

Boise apartment vacancy fell from 4.3% to 1.7% in a year, and rents are up 10%. Most of the apartment buildings that came up for sale still didn't sell. The same thing explains both: interest rates.

Blackstone couldn't pay off a $1.3 billion loan. That's the market I want to be buying in.

In October a Blackstone apartment loan hit its due date and couldn't be paid off. It isn't the only one. Here's what's happening to loans written in 2021, and why that's the best setup for buyers I've seen in years.